Some books are just there, demanding to be read as Everest clamoured to be climbed; bigger and more imposing than others – daunting in prospect like some big mountain or steep rock face, but exhilarating and full of meaning when tackled. I have read two massive books recently, and one was like this – Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men; the other, Primo Levi’s Moments of Reprieve, was subtler, gentler, and more welcoming – but both in few pages affirmed life (in the midst of death and tragedy), and both make you wonder if you are man enough to read them - are you worthy, are you fit to get in the ring with this champion?
I have dealt with the Levi elsewhere, but here with the Steinbeck. This was the book Penguin sent me for the Blog a Penguin scheme, although I was first sent Travels with Charley, which I thoroughly enjoyed but which could not be more different; strong, yes, but charming, whimsical, much more reflective and forgiving, though with real anger smouldering beneath the surface. (I’ve not posted reviews on either, because I can’t get the Penguin site to accept them!).
The story is simple enough: two travelling labourers find work at a farm in California. One of them, George, is a sharp cookie, wise in the ways of the world, and well able to look after himself. Fortunately, he is also well able to look after his companion, the monstrously strong but simple minded Lennie Small, who has very simple aims in life, a very limited understanding, and a tendency to get into trouble through no fault of his except his weak understanding. They end up on a farm where the owner’s son (Curley) has just married a cheap, fast girl who is already dissatisfied with her lot and is intent on stirring up trouble with the hands. And there is one black guy, who works with them, but is apart.
The two of them have a dream – to save enough money to buy a small place of their own, and to settle there - a dream which comes to be shared with a third member of the crew. But boredom leads to carelessness, to wickedness, and to tragedy, a tragedy as black and intense as hell, and as predictable and as pitiless as a train.
What is extraordinary about this book is it’s density; several strands are woven together in an extraordinarily economical story: this is a very short book, but every word counts. And every word has been cut out of the rock and sweated over and polished, and made into a weapon.
At the end, when the depth of the tragedy has burst upon you, and two men – Slim, “the jerkline skinner, the prince of the ranch” and George are finding an almost wordless sympathy with each other about the terrible things that have happened and which they have done; Curley, a shallow despicable man who has respect for anything except for his own vanity, and who has all the time stood outside the current of understanding and hope asks, (I don’t have the text to hand, so I paraphrase) - what’s bugging those two?
If you read this book and still don’t know the answer, then there’s little hope for you – or the rest of us, I’m afraid.